Why Scent Reaches Emotion Before Thought
A single scent can take you back twenty years in a second. What's known about the link between scent, memory and emotion, what brain-imaging studies have shown – and why that still doesn't mean every scent 'heals'.
You walk past someone's kitchen, and suddenly you're eight years old, in your grandmother's kitchen, on a Friday. You didn't remember it. It just happened to you.
Most people know that moment. The scientific literature even has a name for it: the "Proust phenomenon", after the novelist who described how the taste and smell of a small cake brought back an entire childhood. The question is what's really going on there, and what it means for using scents for emotional well-being.
What matters
- The scent pathway reaches areas linked to emotion and memory quickly, with few relay stations along the way.
- In a brain-imaging study of five women, a personal scent activated the amygdala and hippocampus more than any other stimulus.
- According to a review of the Proust phenomenon, there is at least preliminary evidence that scents evoke autobiographical memories more effectively.
- In a large review on lavender and anxiety, inhalation showed only an indication of an effect, and most trials were rated at high risk of bias.
- A fast route doesn't mean a strong effect: it explains a sensation, it doesn't promise an outcome.
The pathway, in three sentences
Scent molecules bind to receptors in the nose, and the signal passes to the olfactory bulb in the brain.
Unlike most of the other senses, the scent pathway reaches areas linked to emotion (the amygdala) and memory (the hippocampus) quickly, with few relay stations along the way.
That's why a scent can trigger an emotional response and a memory before we've had time to name it.
This is a simplified picture of a complex system, but it explains why scent "feels" different from sight or sound.
What the research shows
1. Personal scent, the amygdala and brain imaging
- What was tested
- Whether a memory triggered by a scent activates the brain differently from a memory triggered by a picture.
- Who
- Five healthy women.
- Scent
- A perfume linked to a meaningful personal memory for each participant, versus a control scent. The same was also tested with pictures.
- Route
- Smelling inside an fMRI scanner.
- Findings
- The personal scent activated the amygdala and hippocampus regions more than any other stimulus, and participants reported that it evoked the strongest emotional response.
- Limitations
- Only five participants, all women. The study shows a correlation between the experience and brain activity, not a therapeutic effect.
2. Does scent really evoke memories better?
- What was tested
- A review of psychological studies on the "Proust phenomenon".
- Who
- Various studies. The researchers gave the most weight to studies that examined real memories from participants' lives.
- Findings
- According to the review, there is "at least preliminary evidence" that scents evoke autobiographical memories more effectively than cues from other senses.
- Limitations
- The number of studies that tested this under natural conditions was small, and the methods differed from one another.
3. And what about anxiety? A large review on lavender
- What was tested
- A systematic review and meta-analysis of studies on lavender – in any form and by any route – and anxiety.
- Who
- 65 controlled trials were included in the review. 37 of them, with 3,964 participants, were included in the statistical analysis.
- Oil and route
- Lavender by inhalation, in massage, and in capsules by mouth.
- Findings
- Oral capsules were found to have an effect on anxiety. With inhalation, anxiety levels fell on average, but the researchers conclude there is only an "indication" of an effect, because of the large variation between studies. Massage with lavender appeared helpful, but it's impossible to tell whether that was thanks to the lavender or to the massage itself.
- Limitations
- Most of the trials were rated at high risk of bias, and their average quality was low.
What this doesn't mean
So what can you do with this
Precisely because the link between scent and memory is personal, you can build it on purpose:
Choose one scent for one moment of the day – an evening, a meditation or a walk – and keep coming back to it.
Notice what comes up for you, without expecting a result.
Share it in the community. Personal experience is a different kind of knowledge, and at the Academy we learn to tell it apart from research.
Where to next
- Lavender and sleep: what the research really says
- How to read an aromatherapy study in 7 questions
- Stress and emotion – topic hub
- Download the aromatherapy and sleep guide.
This article is general information and is not medical advice, a diagnosis, or a substitute for consulting a qualified clinician. Read the full disclaimer
Do you have a question about what you read?
Ask it here and get an answer. An answer grounded in Orly's material, with a pointer to the source, opens up when you sign up.